This site uses cookies for technical and analytics to ensure you get the best experience. Please click the button below to accept and close or read more information
Hertford 01992 306616
London 0207 956 2740

Law Articles

Please note: This article provides general information and may not reflect the most recent legal or procedural changes. Family law develops over time, so please contact us for up-to-date advice on your situation.

Pension Sharing Orders on Divorce and Dissolution: Why the Paperwork Still Matters After the Court Order 17/11/2026

Pensions are often one of the most valuable assets in a divorce, sometimes second only to the family home. Where the court makes a Pension Sharing Order, it can be easy to assume that the difficult part is over. A recent case, AP v TP (Pension Enforcement) [2025] EWFC 190 (B), shows why that is not always the case. The judgment is a useful reminder that obtaining a Pension Sharing Order and implementing it are two different things. If the implementation stage is ignored or delayed, the consequences can be significant for both parties.

What happened in this case?

The husband and wife had reached a financial settlement following an FDR and had also obtained advice from a Pension on Divorce Expert. As part of their settlement, the wife was to receive 48.94% of one of the husband’s Aviva pensions. The final Consent Order was approved by the court in April 2023. However, the pension share was never implemented.

Aviva required the wife to provide information and complete its pre-implementation paperwork. The necessary forms were sent to her on several occasions, and the husband’s solicitors also wrote to her explaining what was needed. The court then made orders requiring her to complete and return the forms. Despite this, the pension share remained outstanding.

By the time the case returned to court, the husband was 70 and wanted to retire. His Aviva pension was his largest pension arrangement. The judgment records that he was unable to draw benefits from it while it remained subject to the unimplemented Pension Sharing Order. The delay was therefore not simply an administrative inconvenience: it was preventing him from accessing an important source of retirement income. The judge described the situation as one that could not be allowed to continue. The obvious solution would have been for the wife simply to complete the necessary forms, but by then repeated attempts to secure her cooperation had failed.

This is where the case becomes particularly interesting.

The husband initially sought to reduce the Pension Sharing Order to 0%. However, the court explained that its statutory power to vary a Pension Sharing Order is subject to strict limits. In particular, the application to vary must be made before the Pension Sharing Order has taken effect and before the final divorce order has been made. In this case, the final divorce order had already been pronounced years earlier, which meant that the normal statutory variation route was no longer available. The court therefore considered whether it could intervene under what is known as the Thwaite jurisdiction.

This is an unusual jurisdiction concerning orders which remain “executory”, in other words, orders that have still not been carried out. The judgment makes clear that this is not a general power allowing the court to rewrite a settlement simply because one party later considers it unfair. There must be a significant and relevant change of circumstances, and it must be inequitable not to intervene.

The judge found that the wife’s continued non-engagement after the order was made was a significant change in circumstances.

At the time of the settlement, both parties had been represented and had cooperated with the process. It would reasonably have been expected that the pension paperwork would then be completed and the pension share implemented within months. Instead, the order remained outstanding for almost two years. The court ultimately decided that it would be inequitable not to set aside the Pension Sharing Order.

That was a serious consequence. The pension share was worth approximately £94,000 to the wife, and the judge expressly recognised that it had been an important part of the original settlement. However, the wife was given one final opportunity. She had 28 days to provide the required information. If she failed to do so, she would lose the benefit of the pension share altogether. The court also made a further costs order of £20,000 against her.

What does this mean for divorcing couples?

The main lesson is simple: a Pension Sharing Order does not implement itself. After the court has approved the financial settlement, there will usually still be practical steps to complete with the pension provider. These may include forms, identification documents and details of the pension arrangement into which the pension credit is to be transferred. Both parties should deal with those requirements promptly.

This case involved particularly prolonged and unusual non-cooperation, and setting aside a Pension Sharing Order is certainly not the normal consequence of delay. It does, however, demonstrate why pension implementation should never be treated as an administrative afterthought.

A financial settlement is not truly finished simply because the court order has been made. Where pension sharing is involved, completing the implementation process can be just as important as obtaining the order in the first place.

For further information and advice on this issue, and other family law issues, please contact us for a free initial consultation.

Back to Law Articles
Resolution
Manor Law Ltd, trading as Manor Law Family Solicitors, is a registered company in England and Wales - number 07977350, and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority - Hertford office SRA number 567506 and City of London office SRA number 568637. Copyright © Manor Law, 2026. All rights reserved.
×

Request Call Back

Thank you! Your callback request was sent successfully and we will contact you shortly.

×